Interview with Genevieve von Petzinger: The First Signs Continue to Speak to Us

· Massimmo Frera · 8 min · 5 foto
Genevieve von Petzinger - photo credit Marius von Petzinger
Genevieve von Petzinger - photo credit Marius von Petzinger

We have the privilege and honor of hosting Genevieve von Petzinger, a world-renowned paleoanthropologist and leading expert in Upper Paleolithic cave art. We extend our heartfelt thanks to Genevieve for her generous time and for sharing her groundbreaking work with our readers. For over fifteen years, she has meticulously documented and analyzed the abstract geometric signs painted and engraved across prehistoric European caves, demonstrating that these symbols are not mere random doodles, but early foundational elements of a shared human visual communication system. Step into a fascinating conversation that traces the deep roots of abstract thought and the earliest origins of recorded memory in human history.
We asked her five key questions, and her insightful answers offer a compelling look into the evolving frontier of research surrounding the origins of early signs and symbols-

Arkeomount: In The First Signs, you analyse the prehistoric heritage of the Ice Age, focusing not on the spectacular animal figures painted on the walls, but on the abstract signs engraved in the European caves. You argue that these abstract geometric signs formed a possible shared "visual vocabulary"/"communication systems" long before writing. Looking back today, is there any aspect of your interpretation that recent discoveries have reinforced—or perhaps challenged? First of all, I can’t believe it’s been ten years since my book and TED Talk about Paleolithic geometric signs came out - time flies when you’re having fun! And yes, I’ve definitely continued thinking about those mysterious marks on cave walls, and some of my ideas have evolved quite a bit.

Genevieve:
One thing I believe even more firmly now is that “the geometric signs” probably aren’t a single, bounded group of related signs. I think that category has always been, to some extent, a modern construct that makes it easier for archaeologists to organize the material.
Imagine archaeologists 10,000 years from now deciding that emojis, quadratic equations, and stop signs must all belong to the same communication system because they are visual symbols created by the same civilization. They are related in the broadest possible sense, but emojis are not going to help you solve a quadratic equation! Just because these marks are all non-figurative doesn’t necessarily mean they belong together, and that’s where I think we have to be careful about trying to turn Paleolithic signs into something like an early alphabet.
With that said, I do still believe very strongly that many of these signs were part of communication systems in the larger sense. But I now think we also have to bring the figurative imagery back into that conversation. If signs and animals appear together on the same wall or panel, there’s a good chance they were intended to work together as part of the same visual message.
I also suspect that some things we currently call “abstract” may not have been abstract at all. Some could be highly stylized representations of real-world objects or features - perhaps hunting equipment, parts of the landscape, or other things that were immediately recognizable to the people making them? So I think we may eventually be able to identify what some of these signs depict. That still doesn’t necessarily mean we’ll understand what they meant culturally, though...
That shift in thinking is actually influencing my current work. I’m now bringing the animal and human imagery back together with the geometric signs in a massive digital archive of Paleolithic art across Western Europe, with the goal of eventually expanding globally.

A: One of the things that struck me most while reading The First Signs was that, although I spent part of my archaeological career in Val Camonica studying prehistoric rock engravings, I had never really stopped to consider how little attention Paleolithic engraved signs have received compared with cave paintings! Why do you think these symbols remained in the background of archaeological research for so long, and what led you to recognize their importance?

G:
For the record, researchers were talking about the geometric signs long before I came along. People such as André Leroi-Gourhan and Georges Sauvet created inventories and tried to organize and understand them, so I’m very much building on a much longer history of research. I think part of the problem is simply that abstract marks are incredibly difficult to approach. If you’re looking at a beautifully drawn bison, you may not know what it meant, but at least you know you’re looking at an animal. If you’re staring at a spiral, a rectangle, or a cloud of dots, where do you even begin?
That probably explains some of the imbalance in attention. There’s also the fact that Paleolithic animal and human imagery can be absolutely breathtaking. Some of the paintings and figurines are technically extraordinary, and for a long time there was this sense of astonishment that people living tens of thousands of years ago could produce art of that quality. Naturally, researchers wanted to understand who these people were.
The other major change was technology. To really understand thousands of geometric signs spread across hundreds of caves, you need to bring them together in one place so you can start seeing patterns across sites and regions. That’s what I began doing during my MA, and in one form or another I’ve been doing it ever since.
What excites me now is the scale that new technology makes possible. We’re getting closer to being able to examine the movement of people, symbols, and ideas not just between individual caves or regions, but potentially across entire continents.

A: In recent years, technologies such as 3D scanning, digital imaging and AI-assisted pattern recognition have become increasingly important in archaeology. Which of these developments do you think has the greatest potential to advance our understanding of Paleolithic symbolic behaviour over the next decade?

G:
Funny you should ask, because I’ve leaned very heavily into exactly these technologies over the past three years!
The large archive I mentioned earlier has now developed into an AI-integrated research environment called LIACARA: the Living Intelligent Archive of Ancient Culture, Art and Relational Archaeology, or LIA for short. It brings together academic literature, multimedia archives, a massive graph database, GIS, and other research tools, and our team is currently exploring everything from visual reasoning to 3D reconstruction.
This is essentially the research resource I’ve wanted to build for more than a decade, and it’s incredibly exciting to see it coming to life in ways I honestly couldn’t have imagined even a few years ago. For me, the biggest potential isn’t one individual technology in isolation. It’s what happens when you connect them. A 3D model is useful. GIS is useful. AI-assisted image analysis is useful. But when those different forms of evidence can interact inside the same research environment, you suddenly have the possibility of asking much bigger questions about movement, chronology, visual traditions, and relationships between sites. And importantly, once the first phase is complete, the system will be open-source and accessible to both researchers and the public. I’m building this for all of us.

A: Having spent part some time documenting and studying rock art, I've often wondered whether we sometimes focus too much on interpreting the meaning of individual symbols rather than considering the experience of creating them. Do you think the act of making these signs may have been just as important as the signs themselves?

G:
Absolutely. I think it’s completely natural that our curious hominin brains want to decode ancient messages! We see a strange symbol on a cave wall and immediately want to know, “What does it mean?” I have no doubt that many of these marks were meaningful and intentional. The problem is that the cultural knowledge needed to fully understand them disappeared with the people who made them.
That’s why I think the growing interest in the act of mark-making itself is so important. Instead of only asking what a finished mark represents, we can ask how it was made, what movements were involved, whether the action was repeated, who might have been able to participate, and how the physical environment shaped the experience.
My colleague Barbara Oosterwijk is doing really fascinating work in this area. She studies the embodied process of making some of the oldest and most abstract marks in European caves (mostly spit-painting and marks made with fingers and hands), and I think that kind of research gives us a very different and potentially fruitful way into the material.
We may never be able to translate every ancient sign, but we can still learn an enormous amount by reconstructing what people were actually doing when they made them.

A: After all these years of studying the earliest signs made by our ancestors, what question still keeps you awake at night? In other words, what is the mystery you would most like to see solved during your lifetime?

G:
Ha! I have several of those 🤓😂.
The one that’s really got me curious at the moment is: where and when did Homo sapiens start making figurative art?
We now have increasingly convincing evidence that Neanderthals and Denisovans were capable of deliberate mark-making, and our own ancestors in Africa were certainly creating abstract designs on portable objects by around 100,000 years ago. So why does figurative imagery, particularly animals, become such a distinctive part of the Homo sapiens story? And where did that shift happen?
Once our ancestors dispersed widely beyond Africa, animal imagery appears across an enormous geographic area. That makes me wonder whether the tradition may have begun earlier than the surviving evidence currently shows. Was it somewhere in East Africa? Did it emerge along the routes through the Arabian Peninsula? Was there a cultural development before or during those early dispersals that we simply haven’t found yet?
That is a question I would very, very much like to start answering in my lifetime.

El Castillo - photo credit D. von Petzinger
El Castillo - photo credit D. von Petzinger
Typology -  photo credit G. von Petzinger
Typology - photo credit G. von Petzinger


Tutte le foto · 8